Siesta Key Restaurants Directory

Siesta Key is famous for its powder-white beaches, laid-back island vibe, and an impressive variety of restaurants. Whether you’re craving fresh Gulf seafood, a romantic dinner, or a quick beach café, you’ll find plenty of options on Siesta Key.

Our Siesta Key restaurants directory helps locals and visitors discover the top dining spots on the island. Use the search below to find restaurants by cuisine, location, or style — and check out our featured picks for the best dining in Siesta Key.

Explore the Best Restaurants in Siesta Key

Featured Restaurants in Siesta Key

Siesta Key Village

Seafood

American & Casual

  • The Cottage – Eclectic, international-influenced menu with seafood; popular brunch spot

  • The Hub Baja Grill – Vibrant Baja-style tacos, hand-squeezed margaritas

  • Cafe Gabbiano – Italian cuisine in a dedicated restaurant and bar.

  • Dutch Valley – Down-home American cooking since 1979.

  • Sun Garden Cafe – Popular for breakfast and brunch in a peaceful garden setting.

  • MVP – My Village Pub – Sports-centric pub with burgers, wings, and lots of TVs.

  • Island House Tap & Grill – Casual eats and bowls, small but solid beer and wine selection.

  • Gilligan's Island Bar & Grill – Known for its large tiki bar, casual meals, and beach vibe.

  • The Old Salty Dog – Seafood and American fare, dog-friendly, hallmark “Salty Dog” hot dog.

  • Plaza de Toros Mexico Bar & Grill – Mexican food like fajitas, ceviche, and carne asada.

  • Pi Pizza 3.14 – Casual pizza spot with craft beers.

  • Lenny’z Pizza & Island Bar – Pizza, wings, burgers, and cocktails.

  • Cafe Gabbiano – (Also serves Italian dishes; listed above).

Coffee & Desserts

Southern Siesta Key / Turtle Beach Region Restaurants

Seafood

  • Ophelia’s on the Bay – Upscale waterfront dining with fine food and scenic bay views.

  • Turtle's Restaurant – Casual waterfront lunch and dinner spot, accessible by boat.

  • Turtle Beach Grill – Open-air, casual with live music; located at Turtle Beach (check current status as site availability may vary).

Casual & Unique

  • Daiquiri Deck South Siesta Key – Frozen drinks, casual food, good vibes on poles above ground/“The Backyard” area daiquiridecksouthsiesta.com.

  • Spearfish Grille (just off Crescent Beach) – Marina-adjacent fish sandwiches, casual eats, lounge vibe Sea Shell Condos.

  • Clayton’s Siesta Grille – Creative American with Mediterranean touches and wood-fired pizzas Sea Shell Condos.

  • Anna’s Deli – Known for the “Surfer Sandwich,” featured on Food Network Sea Shell Condos.

  • Jake’s Ice Cream – Dozens of flavors, including plant-based and custom options Sea Shell Condos.

  • The Boatyard Waterfront Bar & Grill – Grouper fingers, smoked fish dip, outdoor waterfront seating.

FAQs About Siesta Key Restaurants

What food is Siesta Key known for?

Siesta Key is known for fresh Gulf seafood, especially grouper, snapper, and shrimp. Many restaurants also serve Florida favorites like fish tacos, stone crab, and tropical cocktails.

Where are the best restaurants in Siesta Key?

The majority of Siesta Key restaurants are located in Siesta Village and along the beachfront areas near Ocean Boulevard and Midnight Pass Road.

Can you find fine dining in Siesta Key?

Yes, in addition to casual beach bars, Siesta Key has upscale restaurants offering waterfront dining and chef-driven menus. Ophelia’s on the Bay is a top choice for romantic dinners.

Do Siesta Key restaurants offer takeout or delivery?

Many local restaurants provide takeout, curbside pickup, and delivery through apps or direct ordering — perfect for enjoying dinner on the beach or at your rental.

Beach View of Crescent Beach from the Casa Blanca

ATTENTION: THIS IS ONLY A INFORMATIONAL SITE AND NOT ASSOCIATED WITH ANY GOVERNMENT ORGANIZATIONS.

Affiliate Disclosure

Join Email List for Newsletter and Other Siesta Key Beach Information