Best Pizza in Siesta Key FL?

Discovering the Best Pizza in Siesta Key

When it comes to pizza, Siesta Key might just be the best-kept secret on Florida's Gulf Coast. This laid-back beach town is home to some seriously awesome pizza joints that cater to every kind of pizza lover, from fans of traditional pies to those who crave something a bit more adventurous. Whether you're in the mood for a classic slice or something with a bit of a twist, Siesta Key has got you covered. Let’s dive into some of the best spots to grab a slice on the island!

Pizza N' Brew: A Local Favorite

Located at 5238 Ocean Blvd, Pizza N' Brew is a go-to spot for both locals and visitors. This place perfectly captures the chill vibe of Siesta Key with its relaxed atmosphere and delicious wood-fired pizzas. Each pizza here is crafted with care, featuring a perfectly crispy crust and toppings that are bursting with flavor. But Pizza N’ Brew doesn’t just stop at pizza—they also offer a range of other tasty dishes like salads, sandwiches, and pasta. It’s the kind of place where you can kick back, enjoy good food, and really soak in the Siesta Key experience.

Hours: 11am to 10pm (Sunday to Thursday), 11am to 11pm (Friday and Saturday).
Phone: (941) 349-4490.

Flavio's Brick Oven Pizza & Bar: Authentic Italian Delight

If you’re looking for authentic brick-oven pizza, Flavio's Brick Oven Pizza & Bar at 6631 Midnight Pass Rd is the spot for you. The pizzas here are made with high-quality ingredients and cooked to perfection in a traditional brick oven, giving them that perfect charred crust that pizza enthusiasts love. Flavio's menu is packed with options—from classic favorites to unique combinations that push the boundaries of traditional pizza. They also serve up mouthwatering pasta dishes, fresh salads, and hearty calzones. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, Flavio’s delivers a pizza experience that’s truly unforgettable.

Hours: 4pm to 10pm (Sunday to Thursday), 4pm to 11pm (Friday and Saturday).
Phone: (941) 349-0995.

Sal's Pizzeria & Pasta House: A Siesta Key Tradition

A true Siesta Key institution, Sal's Pizzeria & Pasta House has been serving up delicious pizza since 1978. Located at 5125 Ocean Blvd, this family-owned spot has perfected the art of classic pizza over the decades. The secret to their success? High-quality ingredients and recipes that have stood the test of time. When you step into Sal’s, you’re not just grabbing a slice—you’re experiencing a piece of Siesta Key history. The warm, welcoming atmosphere makes it easy to see why Sal’s has been a favorite for so long. And while the pizza is the star of the show, don’t forget to check out their amazing pasta dishes, too!

Hours: 11am to 10pm (Sunday to Thursday), 11am to 11pm (Friday and Saturday).
Phone: (941) 349-2212.

Il Panificio: An Authentic Italian Experience

For a true taste of Italy in Siesta Key, look no further than Il Panificio. Situated at 215 Avenida Madera, this cozy spot offers some of the best wood-fired pizza around. Every pizza at Il Panificio is made with passion and expertise, resulting in a pie that’s as close to authentic Italian as you’ll find without booking a flight to Naples. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it a great place to relax and enjoy a meal with friends or family. Along with their incredible pizzas, Il Panificio also serves up a variety of other Italian specialties that will leave you craving more.

Hours: 10am to 10pm (Sunday to Thursday), 10am to 11pm (Friday and Saturday).
Phone: (941) 346-2500.

Ripfire Pizza & BBQ: A Flavorful Fusion

If you’re in the mood for something a little different, Ripfire Pizza & BBQ at 11301 Midnight Pass Rd is a must-visit. This spot combines the best of both worlds by offering wood-fired pizzas with a smoky twist, thanks to their barbecue influence. The result is a pizza that’s packed with bold, mouthwatering flavors. But that’s not all—Ripfire also serves up some of the best barbecue dishes around, making it the perfect spot for anyone who loves a good food fusion. Whether you’re in the mood for pizza, barbecue, or both, Ripfire promises a dining experience you won’t forget.

Hours: 11am to 10pm (Sunday to Thursday), 11am to 11pm (Friday and Saturday).
Phone: (941) 349-5200.

Conclusion: Siesta Key A Pizza Lover's Paradise?

Siesta Key isn’t just known for its stunning beaches—it’s also home to some of the best pizza around. From traditional brick-oven pies to wood-fired masterpieces with a twist, the pizzerias on Siesta Key offer something for everyone. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, these pizza spots are sure to satisfy your cravings and give you a taste of what makes Siesta Key so special. So next time you’re on the island, make sure to stop by one (or all) of these great pizzerias and enjoy a slice of paradise!

Siesta Key Pizza Restaurants